Three boxes each hold two coins, and each box is a different mix of gold and silver.
- Box 1 holds two gold coins.
- Box 2 holds two silver coins.
- Box 3 holds one gold coin and one silver coin.
You pick a box at random and pull out one coin without looking, and it is gold, so what is the chance that the other coin in that box is also gold?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
2 in 3
There are three gold coins you could have pulled out, and two of them come from Box 1, whose other coin is also gold. Only one comes from Box 3, whose other coin is silver. So the chance is 2 out of 3. The quick answer 1 in 2 treats the two remaining coins as equally likely, which they are not.