The lights went out for two minutes, and a rare first edition vanished from its glass case. Four suspects each give an alibi, and only one of them is lying.
- Penny: it was pitch black, with no candles and no phones, so she couldn't see her own hand.
- Nora: she was by the window and couldn't see a thing, so she froze.
- Felix: he was reading chapter twelve the whole time and didn't notice anything.
- Gita: she was holding the shop door open for the cat.
Who is lying: Penny, Nora, Felix or Gita?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Felix
Felix says he read chapter twelve during the blackout. With no candles, no phones and no light for two minutes, nobody can read a page. The other three alibis are about not being able to see or about doing something else, and they fit the darkness.