🔴 Riddle #49 of 240
On an island of knights and knaves, you ask Amy how many knights there are among Amy, Bill and Carol, but you don't hear her answer. Bill tells you: "Amy said there is exactly one knight among us." Carol says: "Don't believe Bill — he is lying." What are Bill and Carol?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
Bill knave, Carol knight
If Bill were a knight, the counts would contradict Amy's type, so Bill lies, which makes Carol's accusation true and Carol a knight (Amy's own type is not determined).