🔴 Riddle #230 of 240
You are offered a choice of two envelopes, one containing twice as much money as the other. You pick one, open it, and find $100. A friend argues: 'The other envelope holds either $50 or $200, equally likely, so its expected value is $125 — you should always switch.' What is wrong with this argument?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
The 50/50 'equally likely' step is invalid
Treating the seen amount as equally likely to be the smaller or larger envelope is not a valid probability assignment, and a consistent calculation gives switching no advantage.