🧠 Riddle #68 of 232
On an island where everyone either always tells the truth or always lies, a visitor asks Pip: 'Do you always tell the truth?' — but cannot hear the reply. Quin then says: 'Pip said that he always lies.' Rue says: 'Quin is lying.' Who is lying and who is telling the truth?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
Quin lies; Rue tells the truth
Pip answers yes to 'Do you always tell the truth?' whether a knight or a knave, so Quin's claim is false and Rue's is true, while Pip's type stays unknown.