🔴 Riddle #47 of 240
On an island of knights and knaves, Amy says: "I am a knight and Bill is a knave." Bill says: "I would tell you that Amy is a knight." Who is who?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
Amy knight, Bill knave
Bill's claim forces Amy to be a knight whatever Bill is, and then Amy's 'Bill is a knave' is true only if Bill is a knave.