🔴 Riddle #43 of 240
On an island of knights and knaves, three people speak. Hana says: "Ivy and Jack are the same type." Ivy says: "Hana is a knave." Jack says: "Ivy is a knave." Who is who?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
Hana knave, Ivy knight, Jack knave
Enumeration leaves one consistent case: Ivy is a knight, which makes Hana a knave, and Hana's false claim then makes Jack a knave, consistent with his false claim about Ivy.